BUFFALO, N.Y. (WKBW) — A longtime business that connected the Bronx to Buffalo has served up its final plain bagel with cream cheese.
The owner of Bagel Jay's Bakery and Cafe announced on social media that the Western New York staple is closing the doors to all three locations after 47 years in business.
CEO Jay Gershberg said it's time for the next chapter and thanked everyone for their support over the years.
"There was a lot of camaraderie, not only with staff there were so many customers and I got to see generations of people," Gershberg told 7 News reporter Kristen Mirand.
In July of 1976, Gershberg and his brother came from the Bronx to open Buffalo's first fresh bagel shop. The two opened Bagel Bros before it was purchased in 2000. Then, Bagel Jay's was born in 2001 where they served up anything from a sausage egg and cheese to green bagels for St. Patrick's Day.
"I think we were a place where people could have business meetings. A place that people could have friends and family," he added.
Thank you WNY for an amazing 47-years. Buffalo welcomed a couple of Bronx boys and sustained and motivated us through the years. Raising our family in a community that welcomed us is special. Our loyal staff, patrons, corporate partners and friends have been instrumental in this journey. Now it's time for the next chapter. Thank you for making my business and life so great.
Gershberg said he is "passing the baton" to Brueggers Bagels, a chain with more than 200 locations nationwide that prides itself in producing "authentic New York style" bagels. The chain will open its doors on November 15th. The closest Brueggers Bagels locations to Buffalo are in Rochester.
Bruegger will serve a signature breakfast sandwich, the JayNOURMOUS, in honor of Gershberg. It'll be stacked with double eggs, three meats and melty American cheese.
"I think Western New York will be in good hands," Gershberg said.
Bagel Jay's had locations on Delaware Avenue in Buffalo, Main Street in Snyder and Plaza Drive in Williamsville.
