NewsLocal NewsBuffalo

Actions

‘It needs to be torn down and rebuilt’: Residents share ideas to honor those lost in Tops mass shooting

“I know a lot of other people who haven’t been back in [the supermarket]. It needs to be torn down and rebuilt.”
Posted
and last updated

BUFFALO, N.Y. — The 5/14 Memorial Commission is asking everybody for ideas on what a memorial for the lives lost in the Tops mass shooting should look like.

Anybody with an idea they would like to propose can submit it to 514memorial.com.

Current and former East Side residents shared that even the building still standing is a continued reminder of that terrible day.

Jefferson Ave. Tops
The Jefferson Ave. Tops has been open for business, but several people shared it's still too hard to go back inside.

 “I know a lot of other people who haven’t been back in [the supermarket],” said East Side Resident Arthur Sharp. “It needs to be torn down and rebuilt.”

Arthur Sharp
Arthur Sharp has lived in Buffalo's East Side for over 40 years.

Gail Harden grew up in the East Side and her mother still goes to the Jefferson Ave. Tops as her normal grocery store, but even the parking lot is tough for Harden to look at.

“It traumatizes me. My mother had just left Tops when that incident occurred. She had just walked out when [the gunman] was walking in. I’m blessed to have my mother here.”

Gail Harden
Gail Harden has since moved away from the East Side, but she still finds herself at the Jefferson Ave. Tops to drop off her mother for groceries.

Both Sharp and Harden feel a great way to memorialize the lives lost is to close down the Jefferson Ave. Tops location and replace it with another grocery store in a different area of the East Side.

“There’s all these empty building around here,” Sharp said. “No, I don’t want to go in there.”

“A new grocery store in this vicinity just a different lot,” Harden said.

Mayor Byron Brown announced during a press conference Tuesday that the city will be accepting idea submissions for a memorial starting next month.

He shared that he is aware that there are people who do not go into the store anymore, however, he said the 13 to 15 million dollars listed in the ‘prototypical budget’ for a memorial cannot be used to build a new grocery store.

“We are not here to talk about new stores, because the government doesn’t build stores. The private sector builds stores.”

The size and location of the future memorial will be up to the people proposing, but the supermarket site itself is not an option as Tops is building a memorial of its own on-site.

Jefferson Ave. Tops
Tops has a rendering for the memorial it plans on building at the grocery store.

Anybody within or outside of Buffalo can submit ideas.

A timeline for proposals is as follows:

  • Q&A Submission Period: Oct. 3 – Oct. 23
  • Answers for Q&A posted to 514memorial.com: Oct. 30
  • Design Submission Period: Nov. 1 – Dec. 1